The last meeting was a painful loss in the final seconds for Bollnäs when Villa Lidköping's Christoffer Edlund became the big match hero.
And tonight's match looked like a repeat for a long time.
Villa already had a 2-0 lead after nine minutes.
Joel Broberg entered the penalty area at full speed and slammed in the lead goal.
The early jolt proved to be enough – at first.
Saku Hämäläinen equalized and Bollnäs also later took the lead shortly after the break after brother Riku Hämäläinen shot between the shin pads of the goalkeeper.
Villa then again took over the match.
Goalkeeper Christoffer Edlund first equalized at 3-3 in the 61st minute after a fine shot from outside, and after a tangled situation, Martin Karlsson stayed in front and fired in 4-3 to Villa.
Bollnäs equalized once more when goalkeeper Anton Johansson dropped the ball.
And after extra time, Bollnäs Erik Pettersson decided and set 5-4 and takes the semi-final series on.
On Saturday, they meet each other in a fourth match in Hälsingland.